Most of us know what we’re good at.

Or at least we think we do.

Ask someone whether they’re a good driver, communicator, leader or problem-solver and you’re unlikely to hear, Honestly? I’m probably below average.

We naturally have more context for our own behavior. We know what we intended, remember when we got it right and usually have an explanation when we didn’t.

Other people have something different: the experience of us.

When Confidence Meets Evidence

Imagine telling an interviewer you’re an excellent communicator. You get the job, and a few months later colleagues describe your communication as unclear. Meetings end without clear decisions and important details aren’t reaching the right people.

Maybe you’re a strong speaker but not a strong listener. Maybe your message makes perfect sense when you already know the background.

Your confidence wasn’t necessarily dishonest. Self-perception met evidence.

That’s useful information.

Check Your Calibration

Instead of asking whether you’re good at something, compare three things:

1. What do I believe I’m good at?
2. What evidence supports it?
3. What do people who experience me regularly say?

When all three point in the same direction, you probably have a reasonable read.

When they don’t, get curious.

The surprise can work both ways. Highly capable people sometimes underestimate strengths that have become so natural they no longer seem remarkable.

So keep the confidence. Just check the calibration occassionally.

Know what you do well, where the evidence gets thinner and what still deserves development.

You may discover you’re not quite as good as you thought. You may also discover you’re considerably better.

Both are worth knowing.

Leave a Reply

Recent posts

Quote of the week

“Develop enough courage so that you can stand up for yourself and then stand up for somebody else.“

~ Maya Angelou